Harvard Educational Review
  1. Spring 2010 Issue »

    Unfair Treatment?

    The Case of Freedle, the SAT, and the Standardization Approach to Differential Item Functioning

    Maria Veronica Santelices and Mark Wilson
    In 2003, the Harvard Educational Review published a controversial article by Roy Freedle that claimed bias against African American students in the SAT college admissions test. Freedle’s work stimulated national media attention and faced an onslaught of criticism from experts at the Educational Testing Service (ETS), the agency responsible for the development of the SAT. In this article, Maria Veronica Santelices and Mark Wilson take the debate one step further with new research exploring differential item functioning in the SAT. By replicating Freedle’s methodology with a more recent SAT dataset and by addressing some of the technical criticisms from ETS, Santelices and Wilson confirm that SAT items do function differently for the African American and White subgroups in the verbal test and argue that the testing industry has an obligation to study this phenomenon.

    Click here to purchase this article.
    Click here to purchase this issue.

    Maria Veronica Santelices is an assistant professor at the Department of Education at the Catholic University of Chile, where she conducts research in education, including measurement, evaluation, testing, and higher education policy. She is currently leading a three-year project designing and piloting new instruments to be used in the admissions process to higher education institutions in Chile. She is also participating in a funded three-year project on the expected and unexpected consequences of the National Teacher Evaluation System (NTES) at the teacher, school, and municipal levels. Santelices previously worked at the research and evaluation unit of the University of California Office of the President analyzing admission and outreach policies and at Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE) at UC Berkeley as part of a team that evaluated child care providers retention incentive programs in California. She also worked with the Early Academic Outreach Program at UC Berkeley designing and conducting formative and summative evaluations of some of their academic programs.

    Mark Wilson is a professor in the Graduate School of Education at the University of California, Berkeley. He is a fellow of the American Psychological Association and founding editor of the journal Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives. He recently gave the William Angoff Memorial Lecture (Educational Testing Service, Princeton, NJ) and the Samuel J. Messick Memorial Lecture (Learning Testing Research Colloquium, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia). His interests in measurement range from reforming the approach to measurement in education and, more broadly, across the social sciences, to innovations in mathematical and statistical modeling for measurement, and to the policy and practical issues involved in educational and psychological assessment. These interests are founded on the core practice of developing concrete assessments and assessment systems that focus on educational applications, but they also extend to broader areas, including psychological and health applications. Most recently Wilson has published Constructing Measures: An Item Response Modeling Approach (2004), Explanatory Item Response Models: A Generalized Linear and Nonlinear Approach (2004, with Paul De Boeck), Towards Coherence Between Classroom Assessment and Accountability (2004), and the National Research Council Committee on Assessment of Science Achievement report Systems for State Science Assessment (2006).

  2. Spring 2010 Issue


    Black Women on Education: Complicating Identity and Negotiating Kinship
    Passin’ for Black
    Race, Identity, and Bone Memory in Postracial America
    Signithia Fordham
    From Candy Girls to Cyber Sista-Cipher
    Narrating Black Females’ Color-Consciousness and Counterstories in and out of School
    Carmen Kynard
    Every Good-bye Ain’t Gone
    Iris Carter Ford
    Branching Out and Coming Back Together
    Exploring the Undergraduate Experiences of Young Black Women: A Conversation with Victoria James, Imani Marrero, and Darleen Underwood
    Chantal Francois
    Teaching That Breaks Your Heart
    Reflections on the Soul Wounds of a First-Year Latina Teacher
    Juan F. Carrillo
    Toward a Sexual Ethics Curriculum
    Bringing Philosophy and Society to Bear on Individual Development
    Sharon Lamb
    Unfair Treatment?
    The Case of Freedle, the SAT, and the Standardization Approach to Differential Item Functioning
    Maria Veronica Santelices and Mark Wilson

    Book Notes

    by Debra Chasnoff (director, producer) and Sue Chen (producer)

    How It’s Being Done
    by Karin Chenoweth

    Preschool in Three Cultures Revisited
    by Joseph Tobin, Yeh Hsueh, and Mayumi Karasawa

    Call 1-800-513-0763 to order this issue.